What Causes Acne Scarring? Different Types of Acne Scars Explained

If your acne has settled but left behind changes in the texture or appearance of your skin, you may be wondering what causes acne scarring and why some spots leave a lasting mark while others disappear completely.
Acne scars form when inflammation damages the deeper layers of the skin and the normal healing process changes the amount or structure of collagen produced.
However, not all acne scars look the same.
Some appear as small, deep indentations, others create wider depressions or uneven texture, and some scars become raised above the surrounding skin. It is also common to mistake flat red or brown marks left after acne for true scarring.
Understanding the type of acne scarring you have is important because different scars may require different approaches to treatment.
At Crane Medical Clinic in Little Sutton, Ellesmere Port, we assess acne scarring individually before discussing whether treatments such as RF microneedling may be appropriate.
What Causes Acne Scarring?
Acne is an inflammatory skin condition.
When a spot becomes inflamed, particularly a deeper cyst or nodule, the inflammation can damage tissue within the skin. As that area heals, the body produces collagen to repair the damage.
If too little collagen is produced, the healed area can become indented or depressed.
If too much collagen is produced, a raised scar can form.
Deeper and more inflammatory acne is generally more likely to scar, although individual skin response also plays a role. Picking, squeezing or scratching active spots can cause additional injury and increase the likelihood of scarring.
Why Do Some People Scar More Than Others?
Not everybody who experiences acne will develop permanent scars.
Your likelihood of scarring can be influenced by factors including:
The severity and depth of your acne
How long active acne continues
How strongly your skin responds to inflammation
Your natural healing response
Genetics
Picking or squeezing spots
Deep, painful acne such as cysts and nodules is particularly associated with a greater risk of scarring.
Treating active acne appropriately is therefore important not only for controlling current breakouts but also for reducing the risk of further scarring.
What Are the Different Types of Acne Scars?
Acne scars can broadly be divided into depressed or atrophic scars and raised scars.
Within those categories, several different scar patterns can occur.
It is very common for somebody to have more than one type of acne scar at the same time.
Ice Pick Acne Scars
Ice pick scars are narrow but deep indentations in the skin.
They often look like a small hole or enlarged pore that extends more deeply beneath the surface.
The name comes from their shape: the opening can be narrow while the scar tapers down into the deeper layers of the skin.
Ice pick scars are one of the most common forms of depressed acne scarring and can sometimes be more challenging to treat because of their depth.
Boxcar Acne Scars
Boxcar scars are wider depressions with more defined edges.
They may appear round or oval and can vary in depth.
Unlike the narrow opening of an ice pick scar, boxcar scars generally have a broader base and more noticeable edges, creating areas of uneven texture across the skin.
They are commonly seen on areas such as the cheeks and jawline.
Rolling Acne Scars
Rolling scars create broader, shallower depressions.
Instead of having sharp edges, they tend to have sloping borders that can give the skin a wavy or uneven appearance.
Rolling scars may sometimes be associated with fibrous bands beneath the skin that pull the surface downwards.
Because their structure is different from ice pick or boxcar scars, they may require a different treatment approach.
Raised Acne Scars
Not all acne scars create indentations.
Sometimes the skin produces excessive collagen while healing, causing scar tissue to become raised above the surrounding skin.
These can include:
Hypertrophic scars – raised scars that generally remain within the area of the original acne lesion.
Keloid scars – raised scars that can extend beyond the boundaries of the original area.
Raised acne scars are more commonly seen around areas such as the jawline, chest, shoulders and upper back, and require a different management approach from depressed acne scars.
Are Red or Brown Marks After Acne Actually Scars?
Not always.
This is an important distinction.
After a spot heals, you may be left with a flat red, pink, brown or darker mark. These colour changes are not necessarily true scars because the texture of the skin itself has not permanently changed.
Red marks may be related to post-inflammatory erythema, while darker brown areas may represent post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.
These marks can gradually improve over time, although this may take several months or longer.
A true acne scar involves a change in the structure or contour of the skin, such as an indentation or raised area.
This distinction matters because pigmentation and acne scarring may need completely different treatment plans.
Can Picking Spots Cause Acne Scarring?
Yes.
Squeezing, scratching or repeatedly picking at acne can cause additional injury and inflammation.
That additional damage can increase the risk of both scarring and post-inflammatory pigmentation.
It can be tempting to squeeze spots to make them disappear more quickly, but doing so can actually prolong inflammation and make lasting marks more likely.
If you are currently experiencing significant active acne, managing the breakouts themselves should usually come before focusing on scar treatment.
Can Acne Scars Improve on Their Own?
Some changes can become less noticeable over time, particularly redness and pigmentation.
True acne scars, however, are less likely to disappear completely without treatment.
The amount of improvement possible depends on factors such as:
The type of scar
Scar depth
How long the scarring has been present
Your skin type
The treatment selected
Your individual healing response
This is why it is important not to treat every acne scar in exactly the same way.
Can RF Microneedling Help Acne Scarring?
For certain types of acne scarring, RF microneedling may be considered.
RF microneedling combines very fine needles with radiofrequency energy.
The needles create controlled microchannels while radiofrequency energy is delivered beneath the skin, stimulating a repair response and supporting collagen remodelling.
Because many depressed acne scars involve a loss or alteration of collagen, encouraging controlled remodelling may help improve the appearance and texture of suitable scars over time.
However, RF microneedling is not necessarily appropriate for every scar.
Deep ice pick scars, raised keloid scars and pigmentation may all require different approaches.
Professional dermatology guidance recommends choosing scar treatment according to the scar's type, depth, location and the individual's skin.
How Long Does Acne Scar Treatment Take?
Acne scar treatment is usually a gradual process.
Treatments that work by stimulating collagen do not produce their full effect overnight.
If RF microneedling is appropriate, improvements may continue developing over several weeks as the skin remodels, and a course of treatments may be recommended depending on the severity and type of scarring.
Some people may benefit from more than one treatment approach because they have several different types of scars.
That is why assessment is important before creating a treatment plan.
Should Active Acne Be Treated Before Acne Scars?
Generally, yes.
If new inflamed spots are continuing to develop, they can potentially create additional scarring.
DermNet recommends treating active acne before beginning scar management.
This also means the priority may sometimes be controlling breakouts first rather than immediately treating the marks or scars that are already present.
Once active acne is better controlled, your remaining scarring can be assessed more accurately.
Acne Scarring Treatment in Cheshire
If you are concerned about acne scarring and are looking for acne treatment in Cheshire, Crane Medical Clinic offers personalised skin assessments from our clinic in Little Sutton, Ellesmere Port.
We welcome clients from Ellesmere Port, Chester, Wirral and surrounding areas of Cheshire.
Your practitioner can assess whether you are dealing with:
Ice pick scars
Rolling scars
Boxcar scars
Raised scarring
Post-inflammatory pigmentation
Redness following acne
A combination of several concerns
From there, we can discuss whether RF microneedling, another professional skin treatment or a different approach may be appropriate.
The aim is not simply to treat something because it looks like an acne scar. It is to identify what type of change has actually occurred and select the most suitable treatment accordingly.
Frequently Asked Questions
What causes acne scarring?
Acne scars develop when inflammation damages deeper skin tissue and the healing process produces either too little or too much collagen.
Which types of acne are most likely to cause scars?
Deep inflammatory acne, particularly cysts and nodules, carries a greater risk of scarring than more superficial breakouts.
What are the main types of acne scars?
The main depressed acne scars are ice pick, boxcar and rolling scars. Acne can also result in raised hypertrophic or keloid scars.
Are dark marks after spots acne scars?
Not necessarily. Flat brown marks may be post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, while red marks may be post-inflammatory erythema. These are colour changes rather than changes in the contour of the skin.
Does squeezing acne cause scars?
Picking and squeezing can increase inflammation and damage the skin further, which may increase the likelihood of scarring.
Can RF microneedling help acne scars?
RF microneedling may help improve certain types of depressed acne scarring by supporting collagen remodelling, but suitability depends on the type and depth of the scars.
Where can I get acne scarring assessed in Cheshire?
Crane Medical Clinic provides personalised skin consultations and RF microneedling treatments from our clinic in Little Sutton, Ellesmere Port, welcoming clients from across Cheshire.
Understanding Your Acne Scars Is the First Step
So, what causes acne scarring?
It develops when inflammation and the skin's healing response alter collagen within the affected area.
But the important point is that acne scarring is not one single condition.
Ice pick, boxcar, rolling and raised scars all behave differently, while flat pigmentation left after a breakout may not be a scar at all.
Understanding what type of acne scarring you have allows a more appropriate treatment plan to be created.
At Crane Medical Clinic, we can assess your skin and discuss whether treatments such as RF microneedling may be suitable for your individual concerns.




Comments